Why I don't like the GAC

A real example of why I don’t like the GAC in .NET:

I’m in the middle of restructuring the CruiseControl.NET build file. I create a new build, test it and its fine. I setup a new CruiseControl instance for a project I’m working on, and that’s fine too. I then copy this instance on to the build server and it fails with a TypeLoadException.

Stripping this down, I have an application that runs on one machine, but if I copy it file-for-file onto another machine it doesn’t run. This is the kind of thing that makes the control-freak side of me’s blood boil.

My next thought is ‘so what’s different between the 2 machines?’ The only thing that effects a .NET application’s assembly load routine outside of the local directory, app configuration (which we don’t do in CCNet) and programmatic assembly loading (which we don’t do either) is the GAC. So I look in machine number 1’s GAC and I see a copy of NUnit in there. ‘Hmmm’ (I think), ‘I wonder if that’s it’ (in theory if my build had gone against the version of NUnit in the GAC vs. the directory-local one I thought I’d specified there could be a problem). So I (eventually) manage to get NUnit out of my GAC, recompile CCNet, try again and everything’s hunky-dory.

So what is the point of all this? In my mind the GAC breaks the completeness / isolation concept for building and running an application in an environment. In my mind, I should be able to zip-up an application (as much as possible), drop it somewhere and it runs whatever the machine, given a basic set of environmental requirements. In J2EE world, when you deploy an application in an app server you put your own JAR’s in the application’s own class-path – you wouldn’t put them in the app-server’s global classpath. So (in my mind) it should be in .NET and libraries shouldn’t be in the GAC unless they are part of, or an extension of, the .NET runtime itself.

I especially don’t like that I can build something referencing a non-Runtime library in the GAC and not be given a warning.

The oft-quoted reason for using the GAC is that ‘it saves you having multiple copies of dll’s all over the place’. My response to this is that premature optimization is the root of all evil and that disk space is cheap, and the pain that shared libraries can give you does not merit the storage space / download bandwidth gain.

So in conclusion, the GAC is better than the dll-hell of COM (which thankfully I avoided by living in Java world for a few years), but still isn’t as good as not sharing library files across applications at all. My advice is don’t use the GAC unless you absolutely have to, or all the applications you use explicitally specify which versions of libraries they require.

Advertisements

Firing up the Bird

Like Joel, I’m trying out Mozilla Firebird as my default browser. So far I like:

– Tabbed browsing

– Powerful (and easy) zooming

– … and Googlebar has got much better (a must have if I’m going to continue using Firebird over IE)

First 36 hours in New York

I flew into New York (for the first time ever) on Thursday evening to catch up with an old friend from home who was also visiting the Big Apple. Maybe its because I’ve been in Boston for 2 months (and don’t like it hugely as a town compared with London), but I really love New York already. It seems to have lots of the great things about London and then compresses it together so you don’t have to take a 40 minute cab ride across town to get between ports of call.

So items checked off the list so-far:

– Grand Central Station

– Times Square (like Piccadilly Circus / Leicester Square on steroids)

– Jackson Hole (a damn good burger joint)

– United Nations (the cafe was shut, but I wanted to go to show my support for the organisation even if my country’s government wants to treat it with disdain)

– Empire State Building (the queues were longish but the views made it worth it)

– Staton Island ferry (which is free, and is an easy way to get a good view of the Statue of Liberty)

– Wall St (which was a lot smaller and more like London than I imagined it would be)

– Ground Zero (no comment necessary)

– various bars till 4 am

Photos to come later…